Share this page

Evaluating Human Scoring Using Generalizability Theory

By Yaw Bimpeh, William Pointer, Ben Smith, Elizabeth Harrison

Abstract

Many high-stakes examinations in the United Kingdom (UK) use both constructed-response items and selected-response items. We need to evaluate the inter-rater reliability for constructed-response items that are scored by humans. While there are a variety of methods for evaluating rater consistency across ratings in the psychometric literature, we apply generalizability theory (G theory) to data from routine monitoring of ratings to derive an estimate for inter-rater reliability.

UK examinations use a combination of double or multiple rating for routine monitoring, creating a more complex design that consists of cross-pairing of raters and overlapping of raters for different groups of candidates or items. This sampling design is neither fully crossed nor is it nested. Each double- or multiple-scored item takes a different set of candidates, and the number of sampled candidates per item varies.

Therefore, the standard G theory method, and its various forms for estimating inter-rater reliability, cannot be directly applied to the operational data. We propose a method that takes double or multiple rating data as given and analyzes the datasets at the item level in order to obtain more accurate and stable variance component estimates. We adapt the variance component in observed scores for an unbalanced one-facet crossed design with some missing observations. These estimates can be used to make inferences about the reliability of the entire scoring process. We illustrate the proposed method by applying it to real scoring data.

How to cite

Bimpeh, Y., Pointer, W., Smith, B. A., & Harrison, L. (2020). Evaluating Human Scoring Using Generalizability Theory. Applied Measurement in Education, 33(3), 198–209. https://doi.org/10.1080/08957347.2020.1750403

Keywords

Connect with us

Contact our team

Email: research@aqa.org.uk

Press and media

For media enquiries please contact:

Email: cmellis@aqa.org.uk

Tel: 01483 477 911

Mob: 07795 020 690

Out of hours: 01483 556194

Join us

Work with us to advance education and enable students and teachers to reach their potential.

Apply now